"So I'm Your Puppy Now?" Chapter 4 — Congratulations, You're My Boyfriend Now
I spent Thursday night writing a list titled REASONS NOT TO DATE RYAN BLACKWOOD, EVEN PRETEND. It filled two notebook pages.
Reason one: he was terrifying. Reason two: he knew I was a liar. Reason three: his smile made my thoughts abandon their posts.
Reason four concerned the way he'd called me sweetheart. I crossed it out because it felt less like a reason and more like evidence.
Oliver read the list over breakfast. "You know you can say no, right?" he asked, tapping the page.
"I know," I said. "But Tyler already backed off. If Ryan helps me keep that distance, maybe I can actually settle in."
"Then set boundaries," Oliver said. "Real ones. And don't let him use your panic against you."
I appreciated that Oliver treated my fear as something real, not as material for a campus comedy show.
At ten, I arrived at the student café. Ryan was already there, sitting by the window with two drinks and my favorite blueberry muffin.
"How did you know?" I asked, eyeing the muffin.
"Oliver told Noah," Ryan said. "Apparently your friends are easier to negotiate with than you are."
"Oliver is a traitor," I muttered. Then I took the muffin because principles were difficult on an empty stomach.
Ryan pushed a folded sheet of paper across the table. Across the top, he'd written: FAKE BOYFRIEND AGREEMENT.
"You made a contract?" I asked. "Are you secretly eighty years old?"
"You told the entire university I beg for cuddles," Ryan replied. "I thought paperwork might restore some dignity."
I unfolded it. Rule one: neither person would be required to kiss, touch, or share private information without permission.
Rule two: neither person could invent new relationship stories without checking with the other. I winced at the phrasing.
Rule three: the arrangement would last two weeks, then we'd decide whether to continue or end it publicly.
Rule four: if Tyler or anyone else harassed me, I would tell Ryan or campus staff rather than handle it alone.
"This is surprisingly reasonable," I admitted. "I expected something about carrying your books and polishing your shoes."
"I considered it," Ryan said. "But I don't own fancy shoes, and you'd probably charge me for labor."
I looked at him over the paper. "What's in this for you?"
He rested his chin on his hand. "Entertainment. And maybe the chance to see Tyler learn some manners."
"So I'm your personal sitcom?" I asked.
"Only if you agree," he replied. "I won't force you to keep lying."
I hesitated, then signed. Ryan signed beneath me and immediately took a photograph of the page.
"Evidence," he explained. "In case you tell people I proposed marriage at the coffee shop."
"You'd be lucky," I said. "I have excellent standards."
"You chose me," he pointed out.
"Under extreme circumstances," I replied. "You were the tallest name on the wall."
Ryan laughed. The sound warmed the space between us before I could remind myself not to enjoy it.
ADVERTISEMENT
We spent twenty minutes discussing what a fake couple should do. Ryan suggested holding hands in public. I suggested standing six feet apart.
"That's not a relationship," he said. "That's a court order."
"A romantic court order," I corrected. "Very modern."
Eventually we agreed on walking together between classes, sitting together at lunch twice a week, and answering questions without inventing impossible history.
Ryan added one more condition. "You have to stop telling people I cry when you don't text. Noah won't let me live it down."
"But what if you do cry?" I asked innocently. "I wouldn't want to invalidate your feelings."
Ryan leaned forward. "Careful, Parker. I'm starting to think you enjoy provoking me."
I nearly choked on my coffee. "I enjoy remaining alive, actually. That's the entire reason we're here."
His expression softened. "You're safe at this table," he said. "You know that, right?"
The sincerity caught me off guard. I nodded, suddenly unable to manufacture a joke.
When we left, Madison spotted us outside the café. She froze, phone halfway out of her pocket, eyes darting between our faces.
Ryan casually held out his hand. He didn't grab mine. He simply waited, giving me the chance to choose.
I slipped my fingers into his. His palm was warm, and the size difference was frankly unnecessary.
Madison gasped. "Oh my God. It's real."
"Of course it is," Ryan said smoothly. "My boyfriend just made me sign paperwork. He's very demanding."
I glared at him. He squeezed my hand once, smiling like he'd won a private argument.
After the café meeting, Ryan walked beside me toward the lecture hall. Every few steps, someone glanced at our joined hands.
I kept expecting him to release me once Madison disappeared. He didn't, although his grip remained loose enough that I could pull away.
"You know," I said, "you don't have to act this convincing. People already believe us."
"Maybe I enjoy walking with you," he replied. "You're a surprisingly entertaining conversationalist."
"That is the most suspicious compliment I've ever received," I said. "Please submit it in writing for independent review."
Ryan stopped outside the science building. "I have practice. You have chemistry, right?"
"Statistics," I corrected. "The professor I accidentally called Mom teaches statistics."
He blinked. Then his laughter startled a passing student. "You called your professor Mom?"
"It was an emotional first day," I said. "Please respect my privacy during this difficult period."
"Now I understand why you needed a boyfriend," he said. "Someone has to protect you from your own mouth."
I stuck out my tongue before remembering that we were adults in public. Ryan looked delighted by the lapse.
He took out his phone. "Give me your number. We should be able to contact each other if plans change."
I dictated the digits. He called immediately, making my phone vibrate in my pocket.
"There," he said. "Now you have a real number for your imaginary boyfriend."
I saved him as PUBLIC SAFETY HAZARD while he watched. He pretended to be wounded, pressing a hand dramatically to his chest.
"You wound me, Jamie. After everything we've been through together."
"We've been through one coffee and a minor legal negotiation," I replied. "Try not to become sentimental."
He looked at my screen again. "I'm changing your contact name to Trouble."
"That's unfair," I said. "I'm very responsible when nobody asks me unexpected questions."
Ryan's gaze held mine for a beat. "Then here's one you can think about. Do you actually want this to work?"
I glanced at the students passing us. My first instinct was to joke. Instead, I nodded slowly.
"For two weeks," I said. "I want to feel normal here. Even if the normal part is completely ridiculous."
"Two weeks," Ryan agreed. "We'll take it one day at a time."
That evening, I received a message from an unknown number. Morning, baby. Don't forget breakfast. — Your emotionally dependent puppy.
I stared at it for a full minute. Then I saved his contact as PUBLIC SAFETY HAZARD and wondered what I'd agreed to.
ADVERTISEMENT
You May Also Like
-
CompletedChapter 16
The Profiler's Broken Silence
Clara was the most brilliant criminal profiler in the city, gifted with the power to expose any monster with her sketches. But her world shatters when her own husband, Sebastian, betrays her to protect the man who destroyed her family. After her hands are broken and her loved ones are gone, Clara realizes that love was just a gilded cage. Now, she doesn't want his apologies—she wants his downfall.Glow-Up|Possessive Love|Second Chance|BE17.9k words5 128 -
CompletedChapter 20
Tainted Crown: A Tale of Sin and Sovereignty
Born in the freezing mud of the Lowlands, Solene learned early that survival has a price. When her mother trades their poverty for a place in Earl Dagon’s opulent mansion, Solene steps into a world of sparkling gems and deadly secrets. Behind her mask of a "Saint," she orchestrates a symphony of revenge, turning the imperial family into her puppets. The Prince, the Empire’s Golden Sun, thinks he can save her—but he is just another pawn in her cold-blooded game.Glow-Up|OE37.1k words5 103 -
CompletedChapter 12
Unloving You: A Rebirth of Letting Go
In his past life, Julian spent ten years chasing a woman who saw him only as a burden. He ruined her happiness, and in the end, she died saving him. Given a miraculous second chance, Julian wakes up on the very day of his 56th failed confession. This time, instead of flowers and pleading, he hands the bouquet to the man she truly loves. "I'm letting you go, Scarlett," he whispers. But as Julian packs his bags to disappear forever, the cold and powerful Scarlett begins to feel a suffocating panic. Why is the boy who once worshipped her now looking at her with such indifferent eyes?Glow-Up|Possessive Love|Fake Relationship|OE17.0k words5 74 -
CompletedChapter 6
The Beast Handler's Seduction
In the depths of Sector Alpha, Dawn is the only human the bio-experiments trust. But after a laboratory glitch, the lines between caretaker and prey blur. Her subjects—a possessive Kraken, a longing Merman, and a lethal Jellyfish—have evolved. They no longer want food; they want her. As forbidden desires clash with cold steel of the lab, Dawn must decide if she is their master, or their ultimate prize.Spirits|Instant Marriage|HE5.2k words5 46 -
CompletedChapter 12
Breaking the Ties of Love
Five years of marriage, five years of hell. Clara loved Xavier with every fiber of her being, but to him, she was nothing but a criminal—the monster who supposedly ruined his lover and crippled his sister. Locked away in a cold basement, Clara endured endless torment as penance for sins she never committed. But when the truth finally surfaces, Xavier falls to his knees, begging for a second chance. Too late. The Clara who loved him is already dead, and she is ready to walk into the darkness to escape him forever.Possessive Love|Love After Marriage|Second Chance|BE16.6k words5 61 -
CompletedChapter 13
The 999th Night: From Lovers to Strangers
After 999 nights of passion, Selina thought she was Julian's world. But to him, she was just a "placeholder" to kill time until his true love, Nina, returned. When a car crash forced him to choose, he protected Nina without a second thought, leaving Selina bleeding in the rain. Heartbroken and finally awake, Selina decides to vanish from his life forever. She books a one-way ticket across the ocean, leaving behind a decade of devotion. When Julian finally realizes that he can't live without his "shadow," all he finds is an empty house and a cold goodbye.Possessive Love|Second Chance|OE18.7k words5 56 -
CompletedChapter 4
The Mafia's American Rose
After catching her boyfriend in a pathetic act of betrayal, Emily’s study abroad dream shattered. Crying on a moonlit street, she expected pity. What she got was Alessandro Romano—a man whose gaze held the quiet power of a coming storm, and whose name made the city itself hold its breath. He offered her a ride. A conversation. A glimpse into a world of opulent villas, unspoken rules, and loyalty bought with fear. He was everything she should run from: ruthless, commanding, and the undisputed head of the most powerful family in Tuscany. Yet, in his darkness, she found a shelter she never knew she needed. But in Alessandro’s world, attention is a double-edged sword. His rivals notice the American girl who dares to challenge him. His protection becomes a target on her back. When an attempted kidnapping proves the danger is all too real, Emily faces an impossible choice: flee back to her safe, ordinary life, or embrace a love that is as intoxicating as it is lethal. He has one rule: what is his, he keeps. Forever. Now, Emily must decide if she’s willing to become the most coveted prize in a war she never asked to join.Age Gap|Sweet Romance|HE5.1k words5 27 -
CompletedChapter 11
After the Divorce, Hearts Came Running
Clara spent five years trapped in a cold, touchless marriage with Julian, the world-renowned surgeon who claimed he couldn't stand physical contact. But on their anniversary, after traveling thousands of miles to surprise him in Edinburgh, she found him tenderly caring for his ex-lover in the rain. At that moment, the rose in her heart finally withered. Julian chose his past; Clara chose her freedom. But when she returned home and erased every trace of him, the man who once couldn't stand her touch began to beg for a second chance.Fake Relationship|OE16.2k words5 43 -
CompletedChapter 10
The Heart He Burned
Clara Joy dedicated six years of her life and all her intellect to saving the man she loved, Julian Pierce. She immersed herself in exhaustive research to create an artificial heart that could keep him alive. However, at the moment of her greatest victory, she discovered that Julian saw her only as a pawn in a game of revenge and protection for his true lover, Vivian. He destroyed Clara's laboratory, burned her dreams, and locked her in an attic on her wedding day. But Julian forgot one thing: a broken heart cannot be mended with lies. When Clara disappears into the shadows with a mysterious stranger, Julian realizes that the heart he truly needs is not the metal one, but the one he himself threw away.Age Gap|Substitute Lover|OE12.0k words5 39